The question
You already sent one or two estimated payments. How do you tell whether the next one is short, and how much of the gap is left over from an earlier date?
Count by tax authority and date
Federal and state payments are separate. Within each authority, record the date and amount. A payment counts toward a due date only if it was made on or before that date. A payment made after the date still lowers the balance if you file now, but it does not change what was missing when the date passed.
Use the cumulative view
Each due date has a cumulative requirement: 25%, 50%, 75%, and 100% of the annual target under the regular federal method. Compare the requirement with the withholding and payments credited by that date. The difference is the shortfall for that date. The latest reached date also carries any amount still missing from earlier dates, so the page can show a current gap and its earlier part separately.
What withholding does
Paycheck withholding is treated as paid evenly through the year, so each due date carries its share of the annual withholding. That is why a taxpayer with $4,000 of annual withholding already has $1,000 credited by April 15, $2,000 by June 15, and so on.
Worked example for 2026
Federal tax for 2026 is $11,000. Last year’s tax was $8,000 and the taxpayer qualifies to use it, so the annual target is $8,000. Annual federal withholding is $4,000.
- Required by April 15: $2,000. Withholding credited: $1,000. A payment of $800 leaves $200 short at that date.
- Required by June 15: $4,000. Withholding credited: $2,000, and the $800 April payment counts too, so the cumulative credit is $2,800 and the gap is $1,200, including the $200 from April.
- If the first two payments had instead been $1,000 each, $2,000 would remain for the annual target. With 10 paychecks still available, the extra withholding would be $200 per paycheck.
- If the $8,000 target is reached, the balance at filing is $3,000: $11,000 of tax minus the $8,000 covered.
Late payments and penalty
A late payment can clear the amount without erasing the late history. Federal underpayment interest is computed on Form 2210 with the actual dates. The 2026 Form 2210 and its instructions are not published yet, so the calculator compares amounts and due dates but does not print a penalty figure. Use the official form when it is available.
What the calculator does not guess
- A payment dated after the estimate date is not counted yet.
- A planned payment counts only after you confirm it was made.
- State payments are kept with the state, not mixed into the federal total.
Where the rules come from
The cumulative percentages, the annual target, and the treatment of withholding follow Publication 505 (2026). The penalty form and its instructions follow the IRS Form 2210 page. All example figures were reproduced in the calculator engine before publication.